With the Major league season (Finally!) a week away I thought I should put together a tier-based power rankings.
It may not make sense and there’s a good chance I’ll look foolish but hey this is about putting this upcoming season in perspective. If the mood strikes I may do this repeatedly throughout the season (who knows?). Lets get into it.
WE ARENT TRYING
30. Pittsburgh Pirates- Look, this team isn’t trying and we offer you exhibit A and exhibit B. Bob Nutting- the owner of the Pirates- is a billionaire and he’s trying to have a payroll barely above $30M. I know fans are going to complain that the new CBA doesn’t include salary floor language but the reality is that would’ve been the entree for owners to put a salary cap in baseball. I’m not saying that it wouldn’t have been mutually beneficial but as a fan of a (finally!) big market team after years of not acting like one- it would’ve sucked. This is an example of a team that will only go as far as the owner is willing to spend a buck.
29. Arizona Diamondbacks- This is another team that’s trying to convince their fanbase that better times are ahead which when you look at their farm system they are correct. They have a consensus top 10 farm in baseball depending on who’s ranking. They just re-signed their best position player to coincide with the arrival of a number of their better prospects. There’s a scenario that this team is a fun team to watch for prospect nerds by July with a few pieces (Zac Gallen) to trade in July that could make this system even deeper.
28. Oakland Athletics- They aren’t 30 because they haven’t traded everyone away and judging by the haul they got for Olson and Bassit (a player in his walk year) they won’t rush to trade two of the better pitchers (Montas/Manea) unless they get EXACTLY what they want. It sucks that owners do this to fanbases but the Oakland fanbase has been through this rodeo so many times they don’t need anyone to console them. This is their purgatory until they figure out where they could play and they just got some very bad news two weeks ago. Oakland could lose two iconic franchises within a 5 year span and its tough to argue. Most municipalities don’t see the economic reasons for building a sports stadium because they don’t see the return no matter what executives in suits try to tell them. As baseball fans it will be weird to see the Nashville A’s or the Vegas A’s but fans should prepare themselves for that reality. What isn’t clear is whether this will prompt the owner to start spending.
27. Baltimore Orioles- It may be harsh to put them in this tier but they aren’t interested in this year. They are another team that has a bunch of prospects that likely won’t make an impact for another year. This is another year where they will be the deciding factor in who wins the division only this time it won’t just be the AL East. With the new balanced schedules, more teams will get to play the teams in this tier and the teams that beat up on these teams with regularity will decide a bunch of divisional races. The Orioles have the #1 prospect in baseball and its likely he will come up in June and justify his standing. But Baltimore has had a highly touted catching prospect come up and not deliver on the goods but folks can’t stop raving about the all around make up of Adley Rutschmann. We shall see.
26. Washington Nationals- This is the team who’s offseason plan made some kind of sense. They recognize they aren’t trying this year. So they signed a bunch of guys to one year deals who they plan on trading midseason to build up depth in their minors. I love that idea and I wish other teams would be realistic enough to do it. But this season is especially important for two reasons- 1. Will the nationals make a legitimate offer to Soto’s camp on a long term deal? and 2. What is left on the arm of Stephen Strasburg. The Nationals former number one overall pick literally sacrificed his right arm for a world series title and a huge extension and he’s set to come back this year. What can we realistically expect? They are a team that the Mets are facing in the final weekend of the year and I fear could play spoiler.
25. Cincinnati Reds- We can talk about Bob Nutting all day but the Reds are another team that made confounding decisions. Traded away a few pieces and likely to trade more after signing guys to some horrendous contracts just two years ago. What doesn’t appear clear is what the timeline for the next great Reds team is. Forget Luis Castillo who’s dealing with some shoulder issue, would the Reds consider trading Joey Votto this year? He’s owed $45M over the next two years total and he just had his best power year in 4 years last year. He changed his approach but was still an OBP machine like he’s always been. I wonder if they would trade him this July to get the best possible return. It would suck for the franchise’s fans who had to watch Winkler put on another uniform but this could possibly be the best solution for the long term health of the franchise.
They Could Be Interesting This Year IF Things Break Right For Them.
24. Texas Rangers- They made over half a billion dollar investment in their middle infield but they have Jon Gray as their defacto ace and a bunch of 5th starters. They aren’t going to be pretty records wise, but this is another team that could point to their team starting to be assembled with ace Jack Leiter needing another year of marination to begin getting some big league time. They have plenty of money to spend in the coming years and will be eyeing the big aces that come free. They may even make a trade or two at the deadline that may not make sense for pitching even if they aren’t seen as a contender. This team could be interesting sooner than we all think.
23. Colorado Rockies- Probably the most shocking signing of the offseason was Kris Bryant getting the bag thrown at him by the Rockies who famously paid the Cardinals $50M to take a perennial gold glover off their hands. This franchise’s front office upheaval is going to make a crazy Athletic article in a few months. Remember how the Dodgers couldn’t win the NL West despite winning 106 games? They can look at their 13-6 record vs the Rockies as opposed to the 107 win Giants having a 15-4 record in 2021. Yes, the Dodgers ultimately made the NLCS which would make it 5 out of the last 6 seasons but these are the teams in this division that are now open season for a bunch of other division races. The Rockies have a legitemate ace in German Marquez and have a stealthily deep farm system and could surprise folks on offense. This is another team that’s going to win a few games they have no business winning early and late and lose a ton in between.
22. Miami Marlins- Derek Jeter quit this offseason and to make Derek Jeter quit something is no small feat. While the reason may be a matter of discussion this is a team that has a TON of pitching. No seriously a TON. During the lockout shortened season they surprised a bunch of folks by making the playoffs but the bones of this team will be their pitching. They locked up their ace Sandy Alcantara to a long term extension and should aim to do so with Pablo Lopez but i’m wondering what their long term plan is to address the other areas of their teams because their top 3 is as good a top 3 as there is in baseball and that’s without counting Sixto Sanchez, or Max Meyer or Edward Cabrera all who flash plus velocity/movement. Do they trade from this depth to get hitting? This is a team that could swing a trade and still have a top 3 rotation for the next half decade. If only they could hit or develop positional talent like they do pitching.
21. Los Angeles Angels- I was wrestling between this and the former tier but i landed here because how do you put them as a team that doesn’t care when you have Mike Trout and Shohei Ohtani on your team? They are starting to assemble a roster around them but nothing is more important than what they get from their starting rotation. Joe Maddon said there are no inning limits for Noah Syndegaard but he’s pitching sub 5 innings in the last two years. He’s signed for a year but let’s be real its with the intent of trading him midseason and advertising him as an elite reliever to net the best return. Its not inconcievable that the Angels FO has sold Ohtani and Trout on this idea to make them stomach yet another year where this won’t be a team that sniffs contention despite having two perennial MVP’s on the team. I can’t even conceive how poorly constructed a team has to be to not be able to build a winner around them but here we are. Bigger development would be Jo Adell being the guy the Angels thought and every prospect hugger thought when he came up.
20. Chicago Cubs- It was legitimately funny to hear the Cubs POBO Jed Hoyer’s “ya’ll should’ve taken the deal when we offered it” spin to reporters when discussing the deals that the former Cubs Rizzo, Bryant, and Baez signed this offseason as opposed to the pre-free agency deals the teams offered. They are a ways away from that 2016 team that broke a 100+ year curse but they are making the moves to that next team. Let’s see how it looks in a year and how they manage to keep trading for high end prospects in deals.
19. Cleveland Guardians- You start team previews believing one thing and it gets to the beginning of the season and something can change everything up. Like locking up Jose Ramirez to a 5 year deal (essentially 7). To put it bluntly this was a 70 win team without Ramirez and a low 80’s team with him. What will change the trajectory of the franchise is whether their hitters will take a step forward or not. Its hard to not view this division as the White Sox, Twins and everyone else showing off their shiny new rookies but the Guardians are in a weird space where they have an abundance of pitching and could use some of that excess depth to trade for an impact bat but are not sure they can afford to make that move until their ownership situation figures itself out (will Dolans stay or will they go?)
COME WATCH THE ROOKIE OF THE YEAR PLAY
18. Detroit Tigers- The Tigers are one of four teams coming into the season that could lay claim to having the best rookie in baseball on their team. Adley Rutschmann on the Orioles. The Tigers will have two of their excellent rookies playing a full season- Riley Greene and Spencer Torkelson who got a great welcome to the bigs moment from Miguel Cabrera of all people. The Tigers started investing into their team already- adding Javier Baez and Eduardo Rodriguez at the top. Riley Greene had an unfortunate injury that has dampened the mood but the Tigers should start seeing signs of rebirth with their core coming on this year and next.
17. Kansas City Royals- Bobby Witt hits like Mike Trout. That’s my scouting take. My toxic hot take is that Mike Trout’s value has been inflated by hollow stats that have lead to absolutely nothing for the Angels franchise. Witt has to hope his team is better assembled than Trout’s. The Royals will feature a young- not great rotation with Royals alumni Zack Greinke at the top and a host of young prospects coming up this year (MJ Melendez, Nick Pratto, Asa Lacy). Let’s see how the young’ns will react to the show.
16. Seattle Mariners- Full disclosure, I think the Mariners make the playoffs. But Swithin, that means they should be higher than 16 in your opening poll. Let me make clear that the season opening polls don’t reflect how I think the season will go, but how the teams open up this year. I like the Mariners. I love that they promoted Julio Rodriguez like the Royals did with Witt, and the Tigers did with Torkelson. The league is overflowing with under 25 STARS that it will be exciting to watch so many young guys develop over the year but Rodriguez is the guy to watch. I think he will be the AL ROY and it won’t be close because as soon as he figures it out, I give the league until May to destroy his confidence, and then watch out. He’s a dude. Those of a certain age know what I mean when I say that. He’s just bigger than most guys and the sound off his bat is what really turns your head. The Astros run of dominance could end as early as next year if they keep letting the talent walk out.
15. Minnesota Twins- Adding Carlos Correa was a legit jaw dropping move. Good for the Twins for doing something that many didn’t expect from them but then again they signed Byron Buxton to a long term contract which many didn’t think was possible either. Either way the Twins will have a guy with a lifetime .413/.443/1.205 line at Target Field play for them for a full year. That’s the highest mark playing at any park minimum 15 games. The Twins and Correa built opt outs that will let both recover if things go south. They still don’t have great pitching despite jus trading for Chris Paddack. But the Twins should have a better offense and they have a great defense so that could mean wins that perhaps weren’t there last year. The Gary Sanchez/Gio Urshela for Josh Donaldson/Ben Rortvedt served both teams well. The Yankees were able to get out from under Gary while getting a better bat in Donaldson and a better defensive backup catcher. Let’s see how this season unfolds but the Twins could be a monster offense.
WE HAVE HOPES AND DREAMS
14. Philadelphia Phillies- Another team I have making the playoffs but inexplicably outside of the top 12. Yes, this is a team that will struggle to defend but you put an offense with Realmuto, Harper, Schwarber, and Hoskins, it will win some ugly games. This is a deep lineup and health permitting they will win alot more games than folks want to admit. The questions for the rotation are thusly: what’s with Zack Wheeler’s arm? They aren’t starting him opening day because he experienced some discomfort earlier this year. Will that lingering arm injury cost him some games this year? If so will Aaron Nola reclaim his former luster as a really good pitcher? Is Ranger Suarez that missing piece of the rotation? Eflin and Gibson are who they are but if Suarez can provide quality innings you have to like the Phillies chances. The hope is that Phillies fans aren’t looking for hope in the bullpen late in a close game.
13. St Louis Cardinals- I really thought the Cardinals would go after Trevor Story. If they did I would feel better about them but with Jack Flaherty’s injury, and their pitching depth down to tiny thread that holds Steven Matz’ self confidence you have to wonder if the Cardinals will truly be a good team. Last year they snuck into the playoffs playing an insane stretch of baseball late in teh season which ok sure- good luck replicating that. The Cardinals have this voodoo magic that the Yankees have. Yes bringing back Pujols was legitemately a cool moment albeit shortlived after he stupidly announced his divorce from his wife days after she had an operation to remove a brain tumor. For the record I agree that divorces don’t “just happen overnight” like he said in his statement but the idea that he would publicly announce something that is NOBODY’s F’ng BUSINESS but their family’s was bizarre. Invoking God’s plan (and no not the Drake song) was even dumber. I can’t imagine God would want you to abandon your wife and mother to your children while she’s still recovering from a major operation. But hey i’ve written too much about it. My point is nothing lasts and neither can the Cardinals devil magic. The decline will start this year.
12. Milwaukee Brewers- I love their pitching. I love their bullpen. Even if they traded Hader, they may still be left with the best closer in the national league- Devin Williams. He’s that good. His change up is basically witch craft and the movement can’t be explained and good luck even hitting it. Their lineup is basically one big question mark around Christian Yelich. The Brewers play great defense and have great pitching- that’s how they will win their division and overtake the Cardinals. They will make moves that seem small and insignificant that will play large roles. They are managed well and built well. More on the Mets future in a second.
11. Boston RedSox- The vibes have not been immaculate in Boston. Devers shot down a contract offer from the club as it was “lower than he is willing to consider.” So good news there. Honestly? The Sawx don’t have the pitching IMO to keep up in the AL East. Alex Cora will have to work his magic even better this year. He has done an amazing job as manager but this division will be an absolute blood bath. Even Cora’ charm won’t be enough.
10. San Diego Padres- I’ve openly complained about how they are able to trade all of their prospects not in the top 5 for really good returns and continue to underperform. Tatis reckless behavior has to be troubling especially coming off the 14 year commitment they made to him. But this is a pretty deep team and they just hired a really good manager that I hoped would come to the Mets before they settled on Buck- Bob Melvin. Melvin’s calming influence will be good and I hope he’s a guy who will let the boys be boys. I just don’t think they will win enough games to reach the playoffs this year especially knowing Tatis will miss half the season.
CONTENDERS
9. New York Mets- I’ll admit that I like this team. Sure. I’ll even admit that I’m higher on them than most. Im more optimistic than most. That can all come crumbling down very quickly. But this is as deep a lineup as the Mets have had ever. I really believe Dom Smith will have 450-500 AB’s. We have a manager who knows what he’s doing and this team will go on a run once deGrom returns that will make folks believe. I still think they are a pitcher short but we will see how aggressive Billy Eppler is at the trade deadline but this is a team that should win a ton of games with a steadier hand leading the team.
8. New York Yankees- The Yankees are a deeper team than they were. They have plenty of offense to win a bunch of games but their defense will be suspect imo and their starting pitching hinges alot on guys who don’t have that kind of track record. The Yankees hope they can sign Judge long term, and they have to secure their price now because who knows what happens. The Giants are a big market team ready to drop a bag on a kid from the Bay Area. The Yankees have to know that they risk alienating their fanbase even more if they let the face of their franchise just walk. If the Yankees don’t sign Judge in the next 24 hours, he’s as good as gone in my opinion. Or the Yankees will have their arm twisted into 1-2 more years than they would’ve liked at a few million more than they would’ve liked. Let’s see how badly Judge wants to stay a Yankee.
7. San Francisco Giants- Can they win 100+ games again? Farhan Zaidi is as smart a GM as they come. They make smart decisions and they are a team that thinks outside the box when it comes to every facet of their organization which has enabled them to beat projection systems almost every year. This team could win 88 games or win 104 games. The reality is they got deeper at pitching and their scientists, i mean coaches will get thier hands on Rodon and somehow helped Cobb add 3-4 MPH on a fastball that was already mid 90’s. Sure. Completely normal. I am not betting against them.
6. Chicago White Sox- They signed Johnny Cueto to a minor league contract so that should tell you where they are in terms of their pitching depth. But the White Sox have the kind of lineup that Tony LaRussa wishes he could manage. Wait, he’s A MANAGER? Either way the Sox will be a really fun entertaining team. They have a solid pitching staff- but that trade for Craig Kimbrell looks even dumber now that they traded him for AJ Pollock who should be a platoon player. I think the WhiteSox will be a one and done team in the postseason but because their division is atrocious they will win it.
5. Houston Astros- Every year they let another guy go and every year they win the West. The Jeff Luhnow tenure left a lot of bodies but it churned out a consistent winner that has leaned on analytics to win divisions and pennants. Every year we assume there’s a downturn and every year they win 95-100 games. At some point losing stars will hurt. This year it was Correa who signed for a deal that a few teams are probably smacking themselves for not offering. But the Astros really really believe in Jeremy Pena and so does my fantasy team. They still have a ton of hitting and a good enough amount of pitching to get thru an AL West that will have 1 teams actively plotting to lose games and shed players, and 3 other teams trying to convince the league they are ready to replace the Astros. I’ll believe it when I see it but it won’t be this year.
4. Tampa Bay Rays- I want to put them in the next group but the reality is there’s a host of outcomes that could rear its head. Will the team be a pennant contender? Sure. Will they win a ton of games because they may have the game’s best young shortstop? Yes. Will they defy convention over the course of a season because they have to in order to survive? Yes. But these are the good times for an organization who shippped off a 30 hr corner outfield bat because they had to make room for a rookie 30 hr corner outfield bat who can defend. They are a factory. A machine created by an algorithm that knows not emotion but cold calculus of wins and losses. Its a tough business but I would’ve loved ANY executive off this team to poach as a Mets fan and I will be a fan of theirs always.
THE FAVORITES:
3. Toronto Blue Jays- They will have definite advantages because they have a great young team with a conglomerate backing them as their ownership. One of those advantages could come as a result of a country ordinance that prevents any player from participating without having received the vaccine. The fact that this game had grown men 20 years ago injecting steroids into their hind parts and has now morphed to grown men scared of a life saving vaccine has me asking this very simple question- where have all the real men gone? The Jays have a stacked lineup and the fact that they were making a concerted effort to pry Jose Ramirez from the Guardians days before the regular season while having already traded for Matt Chapman one of the best defensive 3b in the league show you where this team is in terms of knowing when their moment is. The moment is now. This is a team ready for the here and now.
2. Atlanta Braves- There is no rule that states that I HAVE to put Atlanta at 1 because they won the world series last year. But last year was my worst nightmare because this is a really good team and they didn’t let the emotion of a title sweep them up into making a bad long term investment in Freddie Freeman. Seriously that was probably the scariest part of this organization. It got younger with a minimal drop off in talent and probably better vibes if an Acuna interview is to be believed. Olson is as good if not better defensively, probably going to emerge as a better power hitter if their 2021 season trend lines indicate anything. They have more prospects, and enough pitching to make them great and they won a title without Ronald Acuna. Just let that sink in.
- Los Angeles Dodgers– They are a behemoth. A galaxy destroying death star that if fully operational should have enough to trade for anybody in baseball while still trotting out a middle of the order that reads like an All Star team. If this team doesn’t win this year alot of injuries happened and the Giants and Padres were a lot better than we thought or maybe injuries overtook them and they lost in the world series. This is the ONLY TEAM in baseball that should take not winning a world series as a legitimate stain on their season. They are the best team in baseball and will likely stay up here unless something horrible happens.
ENJOY!